Which weight-loss method is right for me? Eight approaches and the evidence behind them
ca. 20 Minuten

Key takeaways
There’s no one method that’s right for everyone. Concrete figures from German institutions are available for three of the eight approaches covered here, two have been explicitly assessed, and for three we found no reliable information in the sources we reviewed. That breakdown is the key takeaway.
What all the approaches have in common is that they work by reducing energy intake. They differ in the support they offer, the time frame, and how well they fit into a daily routine that doesn’t always go according to plan.
First, you’ll learn what a method needs to be assessed on, followed by the overview and each of the eight approaches in turn. The final sections look at which starting point suits which approach and the limitations of this comparison.
What to expect in this article
1. What a weight-loss method needs to be assessed on
2. The eight approaches at a glance
3. What is actually proven about effectiveness
4. Moderate calorie deficit over several months
5. Guided weight-loss program
6. Formula products as a time-limited starting point
7. Intermittent fasting
8. Low-carbohydrate diet
9. More exercise as the only lever
10. Detox and cleansing diets
11. Nutrition counseling and nutrition therapy
12. Which starting point suits which approach
13. What a DNA test can contribute to choosing a method
14. Limitations of this comparison
15. What you can take away from the comparison
Frequently asked questions
Sources
What a weight-loss method needs to be assessed on
The usual question is which method works fastest. It’s misleading because almost every method works in the first few weeks once energy intake drops.
Three other questions are more useful. Is there a documented figure for what the method delivers over six to twelve months? Does it require support you have access to? And can you keep it up when a week falls apart?
The overview below is organized around these questions. It doesn’t assess which method is better, but what information is available about each one.
What “right for me” means in practice
The wording sounds like a matter of taste. It means something more practical: a method is a good fit if it works with your weekly routine, your budget, and your resilience.
Your weekly routine determines whether rules with fixed times will work. If you work shifts or travel irregularly, it’s the time window you’ll struggle with, not a lack of commitment.
Your budget determines whether guided approaches are an option. Programs with appointments and formula products cost money, and these are precisely the approaches backed by the most concrete figures.
Physical resilience determines the gap between what is needed and what is supplied. During a period of high demands, a small gap goes further than a large one because it can withstand the first difficult week.
For comparison: Two earlier articles cover the same topic from different angles. The Best Weight-Loss Method 2026 compares methods in terms of individualization, while Best Weight-Loss Method: Which Diet Is Right for You starts with diet type. This article sorts approaches solely by the available evidence.
The eight approaches at a glance
| Criterion | Approaches with documented figures | Approaches assessed without specific figures | Approaches without reliable figures |
|---|---|---|---|
| What these approaches are | Supported weight-loss program, meal replacements, exercise as an adjunct | Moderate calorie deficit, detox and cleansing programs | Intermittent fasting, reduced-carbohydrate diet, dietary counseling |
| What the sources say | Specific weight-loss figures over 6 to 12 months (IQWiG, 2022) | A target range set by a doctor or an explicit assessment of the evidence | No figures are available in the sources reviewed for this article |
| Support required | Yes, it is part of the method | No for the calorie deficit, no for the program | No for the two dietary approaches, yes for counseling |
| What happens after a week off track | Support helps you recover from a setback | The phase is repeated or the program starts over | The rules continue to apply from the next meal |
The table is organized by available information, not by effectiveness. The absence of a figure for an approach is not a statement against it, but a statement about the sources reviewed.
What is actually documented about effectiveness
The general recommendation comes before the individual approaches because it sets the framework within which each method must be considered.
It is notably simply worded and names no specific method, just two components.
Documented source
“To lose weight, a combination of more exercise and a change in diet is generally recommended.”
Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG)
Severe overweight (obesity), as of 2022
This sentence does not name a diet. It describes a combination, and each of the eight methods below is a specific way of putting that combination into practice.
Key takeaway
The methods do not differ in whether they work, but in how much support they require and how well they handle an interrupted week.
Why there are no figures for so many approaches
What stands out in the research for this article is less what the institutions say than what they are silent about. For three of the eight approaches, we found no documented information on weight change over six to twelve months.
There is a methodological reason for this. Studying a dietary approach over several months requires people to stick to it for several months and someone to record what they actually eat. Both are difficult to control in everyday life.
The DGE explicitly identifies this problem in its overview of detox diets. It cites an analysis according to which reduced energy intake alone was responsible for weight loss in the diets examined, while the overall evidence was weak and inconclusive (DGEinfo, 2018).
For choosing a method, this doesn’t mean a warning, but a shift in focus. Where figures for a method are lacking, the deciding factor is whether you can stick with it, and only you can answer that.
1. Moderate calorie deficit over several months
The reference approach. Energy intake remains slightly below what the body needs, without eliminating any food group. Depending on starting weight, doctors recommend losing five to ten percent over six to twelve months (IQWiG, 2022).
Best for
People who can plan over several months and don’t need support to stick with it.
For
Matches the medical target range, requires no giving up entire food groups, and can be resumed unchanged after a difficult week.
Against
The change is barely noticeable from week to week, and without tracking, you miss the feedback that other methods provide through rules.
The facts at a glance: no fixed time frame, no food group eliminated, a target range of five to ten percent over six to twelve months, support not required.
Verdict: the benchmark against which the other seven approaches are measured.
2. Supported weight-loss program
This refers to structured programs with guidance, regular appointments, and feedback. These have the most concrete figures in this article.
What studies show over 6 to 12 months
5–6 kg
average weight loss in structured weight-loss programs, ranging from about 3 to 8 kg
10–15 kg
in programs where meal replacement formulas replace meals
2 kg
nearly as much extra weight physically active participants lost after twelve months
Source: Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG), Weight-loss programs and medications, as of 2022
Best for
People who have quit on their own several times and for whom regular appointments make the decisive difference.
For
The only group of methods for which documented weight-loss figures are available over a defined period.
Against
Costs and appointments add up. The average loss of five to six kilograms is less than many expect.
Verdict: the approach with the best evidence and the most sober results.
3. Meal replacement formulas as a time-limited starting point
Powders or shakes replace meals for a limited time. Programs of this kind led to greater weight loss in studies, about ten to fifteen kilograms over six to twelve months (IQWiG, 2022).
Best for
People with medical support for whom a significant initial step is medically justified.
For
The greatest documented weight loss of all the approaches covered here, with a clear structure and few day-to-day decisions.
Against
Eating habits themselves are not practiced. What happens after the phase ends determines the outcome, and no figure is available here.
Verdict: effective over the measured period, but what happens afterward is unclear. Requires medical supervision.
4. Intermittent fasting
Food is eaten within a set time window, often eight hours a day. The sources reviewed for this article provide no substantiated kilogram figure for intermittent fasting, so none is given here.
What can be said: A narrow time window reduces energy intake for most people because a meal is skipped. So the lever is the same as with a moderate deficit, just reached through a different rule.
Best for
People who find a simple rule easier than estimating portions.
For
A single rule instead of daily calculations, with no ban on individual foods, and easy to fit around a regular work schedule.
Against
The time window alone does not necessarily reduce energy intake. If you eat more during the window, nothing changes, and it is difficult to stick to when working shifts.
It also matters in practice which meal is skipped. Skipping breakfast shifts hunger into the afternoon; skipping dinner usually affects the social part of the day. Both matter more for sticking with it than the length of the window.
Why the scale can stay put despite a time window is explained in detail in Why am I not losing weight with intermittent fasting.
Verdict: a rule, not a mechanism in its own right. It works if it reduces intake.
5. Low-carbohydrate diet
Bread, pasta, rice, and sugar are heavily reduced. Here too, the sources reviewed provide no substantiated figure for weight change over six to twelve months.
Some of the early change is due to fluid. When glycogen stores, the body's short-term carbohydrate reserve, decrease, the water bound to them decreases too, and both show up together on the scale.
Best for
People who already eat a lot of carbohydrates and are looking for a clear starting point.
For
The starting point is specific, and reducing free sugars aligns with the recommendation of three professional associations to keep them below ten percent of daily energy intake (2018).
Against
Early success is overestimated because some of it is fluid. Social invitations and the cafeteria become more challenging, and entire food groups are eliminated.
Verdict: a useful starting point for people with high energy expenditure, with a starting estimate that looks too optimistic.
6. More exercise as the sole lever
Exercise works, but on a scale that surprises many. IQWiG notes that exercise helps with weight loss and offers other health benefits, but is generally not enough for greater weight loss without dietary changes (2022).
Exercise is the best way to maintain weight loss and the weakest way to achieve it.
Exercise is the best way to maintain weight loss and the weakest way to achieve it. In studies, physically active participants lost just under two kilograms more after twelve months than those who only changed their diet (IQWiG, 2022).
Best for
People who have already lost weight and want to keep it off.
For
The benefits go beyond weight, and exercise helps maintain muscle mass, which IQWiG says is the main factor determining resting energy expenditure.
Against
As a standalone approach to weight loss, it is generally not enough. Losing barely two kilograms over a year is disappointing for anyone who expected more.
Verdict: Essential as a complement, unsuitable as the only lever.
7. Detox and Cleansing Programs
The only approach on this list for which a professional association has explicitly assessed the evidence. In its overview, the German Nutrition Society cites a study concluding that the effects of detox programs have not been proven and that clinical human studies on the subject are lacking (DGEinfo, 2018).
To explain the visible effect, the DGE states clearly: It is questionable whether such a diet stimulates metabolism, and the rapid weight loss is very likely due solely to the reduced energy intake (2018).
People who want to detox usually have a real concern in mind. They feel heavy, tired, or bloated, and that need is valid. The explanation, however, doesn’t hold up.
Best for
Based on the evidence reviewed, no group can be identified for whom this approach would be suitable.
For
A clear beginning and end provide structure, and many people use the program as a reason to make any changes at all.
Against
Its effectiveness is considered unproven. The DGE also points out that a drastic reduction in energy intake can lower the basal metabolic rate and thereby encourage the yo-yo effect (2018).
Verdict: The need behind it should be taken seriously, but the rationale doesn’t stand up to scrutiny.
8. Nutritional Counseling and Nutritional Therapy
The only approach backed by a regulated qualification. According to IQWiG, nutritional counseling is aimed primarily at healthy people, while nutritional therapy is for people who are ill and is intended to complement the treatment of nutrition-related diseases (as of 2021).
There is a distinction in costs that surprises many people. For preventive counseling by qualified providers, health insurance covers part of the cost, and no doctor’s referral is required. Nutritional therapy, by contrast, is not covered by health insurance, apart from a few specified conditions (IQWiG, 2021).
Best for
People with pre-existing conditions, a difficult relationship with food, or several failed attempts to go it alone.
For
Qualified professionals are defined, the cost of preventive counseling is covered in part, and this is the only approach tailored to an individual rather than a rule.
Against
Appointments and waiting times take time, the treatment is mostly not covered by health insurance, and we have no figure here for the weight change that can be achieved.
Chapter at a glance
Eight approaches, three levels of evidence. For supported programs, meal replacement products, and the contribution of physical activity, IQWiG provides specific figures in kilograms over six to twelve months (2022). For a moderate deficit, there is a medical target range; for detox cures, the DGE (2018) explicitly assesses the evidence. For intermittent fasting, reduced-carbohydrate diets, and nutrition counseling, we found no figures on weight change in the sources reviewed.
This comparison does not cover the medical route involving prescription medication or surgery. Both are medical decisions and are neither assessed nor compared here.
Which approach fits which starting point
The eight approaches above boil down to three starting points. If you have never managed to stick with an attempt on your own for several months, the difference usually lies in the support, not the type of diet.
If you have started several times and quit after a few weeks, the problem is usually pace. The approach with the smallest gap between your needs and intake is most sustainable, even if it feels too slow.
And anyone who has already lost weight and wants to keep it off faces a different task than losing weight itself. For that, physical activity is the proven contribution, not the next diet.
A personal approach makes sense if …
you have been working without a set structure and are looking for a benchmark to track your progress.
you know that rules are easier for you than estimates, or vice versa.
you accept a timeframe of six to twelve months instead of a deadline in six weeks.
Going it alone probably isn't right if …
you are gaining or losing weight unintentionally without having changed anything. In that case, medical evaluation comes before choosing any method.
eating is associated with control or shame for you. None of the approaches on this list addresses that; several can make it worse.
you have a medical condition or take medication that affects your weight or appetite.
What a DNA test contributes to choosing a method
All eight approaches above are rules for groups. A DNA test by mybody®x (MYBODY Lab GmbH) describes traits that do not change, offering clues as to why a rule may have been harder for you to stick to so far.
It does not choose a method for you. It provides context, and that is the honest scope of what it can tell you.

Saliva DNA test
WeightLoss | SLIM DNA test
Analysis of more than 80 genetic variations, presented in 24 reports across five chapters, including nutrition and dietary traits. What the test does not do: It does not identify a method as the right one, make a diagnosis, or predict weight loss success. Your genetic profile does not define you.
Laboratory analysis 15–25 business days after sample receipt
Information from the product page, accessed 07.08.2026
Limitations of this comparison
This article compares the available information, not success rates. The fact that no figure is given for three approaches does not mean they are ineffective, but that the sources reviewed for this article provide no such information.
The figures from [2] come from studies with support. They describe groups over six to twelve months and say nothing about any one person or the period after that.
Also excluded are all medical approaches. Prescription drugs and surgery are deliberately neither assessed nor compared here, because both require a medical decision.
Another limitation lies in the selection itself. Eight approaches are not a complete overview of everything offered under the term “weight loss method.” The selection includes what is common and what a German institution has actually made a statement about.
And the test has the limitation stated in the product card. It describes predisposition and does not determine the choice of method.
What you can take away from the comparison
If you take away one thing, let it be this: Don’t judge a method by what it promises in four weeks, but by whether it gives a figure for six to twelve months. For five of the eight approaches above, that figure is missing.
The second test is even simpler. Ask yourself what happens to the method when a week falls apart. Approaches that withstand this are different from those that end there.
It started with the question of which method is right for you. After eight approaches, there is an uncomfortable answer: the method matters less than how long you stick with it.
Frequently asked questions
Which weight loss method is the most effective?
The greatest documented weight loss was achieved by programs using formula diets, at around ten to fifteen kilograms over six to twelve months (IQWiG, 2022). Structured weight-loss programs without formula diets resulted in around three to eight kilograms, averaging five to six. Both figures come from studies with support and say nothing about the period afterward.
Does intermittent fasting work better than a regular calorie deficit?
We found no substantiated information on this question in the sources reviewed for this article, so no figure is given here. It is fair to say that a restricted eating window reduces energy intake for most people because one meal is skipped. The mechanism is therefore the same as with a moderate calorie deficit, just achieved through a different rule.
Do detox or cleansing cures help with weight loss?
In its overview, the German Nutrition Society refers to a study according to which the effects of detox cures have not been proven and clinical human studies are lacking (DGEinfo, 2018). The DGE attributes rapid weight loss very likely solely to reduced energy intake and points out that a drastic reduction in intake can lower the basal metabolic rate and promote the yo-yo effect.
Is exercise alone enough to lose weight?
Generally not. IQWiG notes that exercise helps with weight loss and has other health benefits, but is usually not enough to achieve greater weight loss without dietary changes (2022). In studies, physically active participants lost just under two kilograms more after twelve months than those who only changed their diet. Exercise makes a much greater contribution to maintaining weight.
Does health insurance cover nutritional counseling?
Health insurance funds contribute to preventive consultations with qualified providers, and no doctor’s referral is required (IQWiG, 2021). However, nutrition therapy for people who are already ill is not covered by health insurance, except for a few specified conditions; for other illnesses, the insurer decides after an application is submitted. Qualified professionals include state-certified dietitians.
Next step
When the method is clear but the rationale is missing
WeightLoss | The SLIM DNA test provides insights into genetic predispositions that can help inform a chosen method. It does not make the choice and is no substitute for medical advice.
Go to WeightLoss | SLIM DNA test Go to the plan instructionsRead more
You might also be interested in
An overview of what a genetic approach to weight loss can and cannot achieve.
The most common reasons why the scale still doesn’t budge even when the time window is set.
Sources
- Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG): Severe Overweight (Obesity) (as of 2022) – gesundheitsinformation.de
- Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG): Weight Loss Programs and Medications (as of 2022) – gesundheitsinformation.de
- Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG): Nutritional Counseling and Nutrition Therapy (as of 2021) – gesundheitsinformation.de
- German Nutrition Society (DGE): Detox Diets, DGEinfo 3/2018 – dge.de
- German Obesity Society, German Diabetes Association, and German Nutrition Society: Quantitative Recommendation for Sugar Intake in Germany (2018) – dge.de
The verbatim quote about the recommended combination comes from source [1], as does the target range of five to ten percent. All figures in kilograms for programs, meal replacements, and the contribution of physical activity, as well as the statement about the role of exercise, come from [2]. The information on nutritional counseling, nutrition therapy, and cost coverage comes from [3]. The assessment of the evidence on detox cleanses, the attribution of weight loss to reduced energy intake, and the note about basal metabolic rate come from [4]; the reviews cited there are identified in the source by author and year. The recommendation on free sugars comes from [5]. Information on price, sample type, scope of analysis, and laboratory comes from the mybody®x product page, accessed on 07.08.2026; processing times follow the central guideline for each test type. All sources were accessed and checked on 07.08.2026.
mybody®x Editorial & Expert Team
Nutritional science Nutrigenetics Laboratory diagnostics Blood test interpretation
This article was created by the mybody®x editorial and expert team. The team brings together nutritional science, nutrigenetics, and the interpretation of blood tests. You can find the people involved on the authors page.
Published on 19.08.2026 · Last updated on 19.08.2026
The content is intended for general information and is not a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Reference ranges depend on the laboratory, method, and age; the information on your test results is always authoritative.

