Are there good and bad genes? Why the environment and trait matter
October 4, 2026approx. 15 minutesby mybody®x Editorial & Expert Team

The key points
There are no good and bad genes in that sense. According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), most gene variants, lasting changes to a gene, do not cause disease. Whether a variant helps or harms depends on the environment and the trait: with one copy, the sickle cell trait offers relative protection against death from malaria; with two copies, it causes anemia known as sickle cell disease (Luzzatto, 2012).
Experts say gene variant instead of mutation because, according to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), changes to DNA do not always cause disease.
A gene can have opposing effects, and according to Carter and Nguyen (2011), this is more common than assumed.
“Unfavorable” in a DNA report is a classification compared with the general population, not a disease.
In this article
Are there good and bad genes?
Not as a fixed property of a gene. According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), most gene variants do not cause disease, and whether a variant helps or harms depends on the trait and the environment.
People who ask about bad genes have a reason for doing so. Perhaps an illness has occurred repeatedly in the family, or a report contains the word “unfavorable.” The concern behind it should be taken seriously. Still, dividing genes into good and bad doesn’t help, because it skips a question: good for what, and bad where?
First, the terms. A gene is a section of hereditary information made up of a sequence of DNA building blocks, the molecule that carries hereditary information. According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), a gene variant is a lasting change to this sequence. It used to be called a mutation, a word that sounds like damage.
According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), most variants do not cause disease, and variants that do cause disease are rare in the population. The US National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI) describes the same thing from the perspective of genomics: According to NHGRI (2023), most variants do not affect how a person’s genome works, that is, their entire genetic information; a small subset does.
An estimate shows how many there are: On average, according to NHGRI (2023), a person carries about 5 million single-nucleotide variants, meaning differences in a single DNA building block, compared with the reference genome, a comparison sequence assembled from the genetic material of several people. Anyone who assumes these are all bad genes is confusing difference with damage.
That leaves the small subset that has an effect. Even then, the outcome is not predetermined. A well-documented example is sickle cell trait: With one copy of the variant, meaning it is present once in the genetic material, it provides relative protection against death from malaria; with two copies, meaning it is present twice, it causes sickle cell disease, a form of anemia (Luzzatto, 2012).
A predisposition is not a disease either. It refers to a gene variant that can affect the risk of certain diseases, as described by MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021). That does not mean a disease will develop.
Key point
A gene variant is not inherently good or bad, but rather beneficial or harmful for a trait in a particular environment.
Mutation or variant: What do experts call altered genes?
Today, they use the term gene variant. Because changes in DNA do not always cause disease, MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021) considers this term more precise than the older word mutation.
The change is more than just a matter of language. Mutation sounds like an error, something that needs to be fixed. Variant sounds like a variation, which better fits what we know about differences in genetic material: A difference is simply a difference, not a defect.
MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021) distinguishes between two types of variants. According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), inherited variants are passed from parents to children and are found in nearly every cell in the body throughout life. Non-inherited variants, by contrast, arise during a person’s lifetime, occur only in individual cells, and, according to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), cannot be passed on to the next generation.
According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), some variants are so common that they are considered common variation, or common genetic variation in English. According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), some of these explain differences between people, such as eye color or blood type.
According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), many of these common variants do not harm health; some can affect the risk of certain diseases. So the word common describes how widespread a variant is, not how it works. A common variant can be unfavorable, while a rare one may have no effect.
The article on genetic differences between people shows the extent of the overall differences between two people. As a ballpark figure, according to NHGRI (2023), two genomes are about 99.6 percent identical on average.
The article Gene: Meaning and Terms explains what the word gene means and how variants and mutations differ in detail; it focuses on the terms, while this article asks whether a variant can be evaluated.
Documented source
“Because changes in DNA do not always cause a disease, gene variant is considered the more accurate term.”
National Library of Medicine
MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021): What is a gene variant and how do variants occur?, translated from English
This is the first finding in the question of good and bad genes: even the old term contained a judgment that technical language has since stepped back from.
Can a gene be both good and bad?
Yes. Experts call this antagonistic pleiotropy: a gene has multiple effects that go in opposite directions (Carter and Nguyen, 2011).
Pleiotropy means that a gene has more than one effect. Antagonistic means opposing: one effect brings an advantage, another a disadvantage, measured in terms of fitness in the biological sense—that is, survival and reproduction.
Carter and Nguyen start with a puzzle. According to Carter and Nguyen (2011), many severe diseases have a genetic basis that, from an evolutionary perspective, should have been eliminated and become very rare. Their explanation: Antagonistic pleiotropy is more widespread than assumed, in the view of Carter and Nguyen (2011). They cite sickle cell disease as an example.
How does the sickle cell gene work with one or two copies?
Having one copy of the sickle cell variant provides relative protection against death from malaria; having two copies causes sickle cell anemia (Luzzatto, 2012).
Sickle cell anemia is an inherited form of anemia. According to Luzzatto (2012), its distribution reflects the past and present distribution of malaria tropica, or malaria caused by the pathogen Plasmodium falciparum.
According to Luzzatto (2012), people with one copy, abbreviated AS, are relatively protected from death due to malaria; this is supported by clinical field studies from several parts of Africa. People with two copies, abbreviated SS, have sickle cell anemia and, according to Luzzatto (2012), are highly susceptible to fatal forms of malaria. The S in both abbreviations stands for the sickle-cell variant.
One and the same variant is therefore beneficial or harmful depending on which trait you consider. For survival during malaria, one copy counts as a benefit; for anemia, two copies count as a serious disadvantage. Relatively protected does not mean invulnerable: Luzzatto describes protection in comparison, not complete protection.
The article on autosomal dominant and recessive inheritance explains how one and two copies of a gene interact in inheritance.
This leads to a classification that Luzzatto does not make explicitly: the benefit of having one copy matters where tropical malaria is present. Where this malaria does not occur, the part of the effect that counts as a benefit is absent.
One and the same variant is beneficial or harmful depending on which trait you consider.
What determines whether a gene is beneficial or harmful?
It depends on the trait in question and the environment a person lives in. A model by Carter and Nguyen (2011) shows that a variant with serious consequences can persist if it provides a small benefit elsewhere.

The model is population-genetic, meaning it calculates how variants persist or disappear in a population over generations. The result: according to Carter and Nguyen (2011), variants with serious health consequences can persist at a medically significant frequency if they provide small benefits elsewhere.
The authors go a step further. If antagonistic pleiotropy is as widespread as their research suggests, Carter and Nguyen (2011) say it could explain why so many serious diseases have a genetic component, including those apparently triggered by the environment. This is a hypothesis supported by the model, not a measured proportion.
For evaluating a gene, this means that a judgment requires two details. The first is the trait: what a variant is supposed to be beneficial or harmful for. The second is the environment in which it acts; in the case of the sickle-cell trait, the question is whether tropical malaria is present.
How a predisposition in the genetic makeup, the genotype, relates to the expressed trait, the phenotype, is shown in the article Same genetic variant, different effect. The article on endogenous and exogenous factors explains which internal and external influences come together.
Terms relating to good and bad genes
| Term | Meaning | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Genetic variant | Permanent change in the DNA sequence of a gene, inherited or acquired during a person’s lifetime | MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021) |
| Mutation | Older term for the same change, replaced because DNA changes do not always cause disease | MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021) |
| Common variation | Variants that are common enough in the population to be considered normal differences, such as eye color | MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021) |
| Predisposition | A genetic variant that can affect the risk of a disease; carriers sometimes never develop the disease, even within the same family | MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021) |
| Antagonistic pleiotropy | A gene with multiple effects that influence fitness in opposing ways; considered more common than assumed by the authors | Carter and Nguyen (2011) |
| One copy (AS) and two copies (SS) | One copy of the sickle cell variant offers relative protection from dying of malaria; two copies cause sickle cell disease and high susceptibility to fatal malaria | Luzzatto (2012) |
Does a genetic predisposition mean you’ll get sick?
No. According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), some people with a predisposing genetic variant never develop the disease, while others do, even within the same family.
For families in which a disease has occurred multiple times, this is the most important sentence on the whole topic. Sharing a predisposition does not mean sharing the same outcome. If you carry the same predisposing variant as a parent who has the disease, that means you have a predisposition, not a diagnosis. It’s best to discuss whether your family’s medical history should be evaluated by a doctor with your family physician.
What does “unfavorable” mean when it comes to genes in a DNA report?
“Unfavorable” is a classification compared with the broader population, not a disease. The result of an analysis comes from the combination of genotypes.
In the gene tables of a DNA report, the genotype column shows the personal result at a site being studied, noted as a combination of letters such as GG or CT. These letters describe which variant someone carries. By themselves, they don’t say whether it’s good or bad.
In the mybody®x DNA test report (MYBODY Lab GmbH) discussed further below, the result of an analysis is derived from the combination of genotypes and compared with the general population. A result might then state that someone has “more unfavorable than favorable variants.”
In this context, “unfavorable” refers to the result of this comparison with the general population. It is a comparative classification, not a disease. The headings of these analyses therefore describe a predisposition, not a diagnosis.
The same rule applies in the report as for sickle cell trait. Favorable and unfavorable are terms of comparison; they need a reference point, which here is the population and the subject of the analysis.
Two questions can help you interpret the results. Which trait does the classification refer to? And who is it compared with? What a result means for your own health is something to discuss with your doctor. The article How to correctly understand DNA test results explains how to read the individual parts of a result.
Chapter at a glance
“Unfavorable” in a DNA report describes a combination of genotypes compared with the general population. It is a classification, not a disease. The heading of an analysis refers to a predisposition. According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), some people with a predisposing variant never develop the condition.
Which two claims about bad genes are false?
“I have bad genes” and “An unfavorable variant causes disease.” Neither stands up to the sources, because according to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), most variants do not cause disease.
Both claims may have a reason behind them, such as a family illness or a report containing the word “unfavorable.” They are not being mocked here, but examined.
Two claims about genes, fact-checked
Common
“I have bad genes.”
Evidence-based
According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), most variants do not cause disease, and according to NHGRI (2023), most do not affect how the genome works. These findings do not justify making a blanket judgment about your own genetic makeup.
Common
“An unfavorable variant causes disease.”
Evidence-based
According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), some people with a predisposing variant never develop the condition, while others do, even within the same family. According to NHGRI (2023), only a small subset of variants affects how the genome functions.
What both statements get right: Some variants can affect the risk of certain diseases, as MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021) notes. The statement becomes wrong only when a single variant is used to judge a whole person.
What does a DNA test reveal about your genes?
The mybody®x DNA test reads selected genetic variants from a saliva sample. It uses SNP genotyping, not whole-genome sequencing, and does not provide a diagnosis.
According to NHGRI (2023), an SNP is a single-nucleotide variant—that is, a single differing DNA building block—that occurs in at least 1 percent of people. SNP genotyping checks specific, predetermined positions in the genome. Whole-genome sequencing, by contrast, reads the entire genome.
mybody®x DNA tests use SNP genotyping, not whole-genome sequencing. The NutriCare | According to the product information (as of October 4, 2026), the INFINITY DNA Test examines 140 genetic variations from a saliva sample. To collect the sample, you spit into a tube using a small funnel; no cheek swab is needed. Analysis is performed at a specialist laboratory in Germany.
The results place the genotypes in context as described in the chapter about the report: by comparing them with those of the general population. What the NutriCare DNA Test does not do is tell you what to do. There is no diet plan or list of prohibitions. It is not a diagnostic procedure and does not replace medical advice.
According to our assessment, this means the saliva test reads DNA variants, not epigenetic markers—in other words, changes that affect DNA without changing its sequence. It provides a starting point, not a judgment about good or bad genes.
From the mybody®x range · DNA test
NutriCare | INFINITY DNA test
Uses SNP genotyping to identify selected genetic variations in your saliva sample and compare the genotypes with those of the general population. It is not a diagnostic procedure and is no substitute for medical advice; analysis is performed at a specialist laboratory in Germany.
Lab analysis 15–25 business days after sample receipt
Information current as of: 04.10.2026
NutriCare | View the INFINITY DNA testLimitations: How far does our knowledge of good genes go?
The claim that opposing effects are more widespread than assumed is an assumption made by Carter and Nguyen (2011). According to Luzzatto (2012), protection from sickle cell trait is only relative.
Carter and Nguyen (2011) draw on a literature review and a simple model. They themselves present the idea that antagonistic pleiotropy is more widespread than assumed as a belief and hypothesis. The model shows a possibility, not a measured prevalence.
For Luzzatto (2012), “relatively protected” does not mean completely protected. The point that the advantage is limited to areas where malaria tropica is prevalent is an interpretation based on the distribution of malaria, not an explicit statement by the source.
A DNA test is not a diagnostic procedure and does not replace medical advice. It describes predispositions compared with the general population; it does not predict whether someone will develop a disease.
What remains of good and bad genes?
A shortcut that promises more than it delivers. A gene variant is beneficial or unfavorable for a trait in a given environment, and the sickle cell trait shows that both can be true of the same variant. If a report describes a variant as “unfavorable,” that is a classification by comparison, not a diagnosis.
A predisposition is not a certainty.
Frequently asked questions
What are bad genes?
“Bad genes” is a colloquial expression, not a technical term. Genetics refers to gene variants, and according to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), most of them do not cause disease. On average, a person carries about 5 million single-letter variants compared with the reference genome, according to NHGRI (2023). People using the expression mean variants that can affect the risk of certain diseases; even these are predispositions, not diseases.
Can you inherit good genes?
What is inherited are variants, not judgments. According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), inherited variants pass from parents to children and are found in nearly every cell in the body throughout life. Whether an inherited variant is beneficial depends on the trait and the environment. According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), even a variant that predisposes someone to a condition does not lead to illness in every carrier, including within the same family.
Is a mutation always bad?
No. Because changes to DNA do not always cause disease, experts now use the term gene variants rather than mutations (MedlinePlus Genetics, NLM, 2021). Some variants are so common that they are considered normal variation; according to NHGRI (2023), a single-nucleotide variant counts as an SNP if it occurs in at least 1 percent of people. Common variants explain differences such as eye color (MedlinePlus Genetics, NLM, 2021).
Are bad genes always passed on to children?
No. According to MedlinePlus Genetics (NLM, 2021), only inherited variants found in almost every cell of the body are passed on. Variants that arise in individual cells during a person’s lifetime cannot be passed on to the next generation (MedlinePlus Genetics, NLM, 2021). Even when a variant is passed on, the details matter: According to Luzzatto (2012), there is a fundamental difference between carrying one copy or two copies of the sickle cell trait.
Why do bad genes still exist?
One possible explanation is antagonistic pleiotropy. According to Carter and Nguyen (2011), many serious diseases have a genetic basis that should have become rare through evolution. Their model shows that variants with serious consequences can persist if they offer a small advantage elsewhere (Carter and Nguyen, 2011). The authors’ claim that this phenomenon is more common than assumed remains an assumption; the example of sickle cell trait is supported by evidence (Luzzatto, 2012).
Next step
Understanding your own gene variants
The NutriCare | The INFINITY DNA test places your genotypes in the context of the broader population, as predispositions and without providing a diagnosis. You submit a saliva sample at home.
Go to NutriCare | INFINITY DNA test Which genes a DNA test examines Guide to the scope and selection of gene variantsRead more
Sources
- National Library of Medicine, MedlinePlus Genetics: What is a gene variant and how do variants occur? (as of 2021) – medlineplus.gov
- Carter A. J., Nguyen A. Q.: Antagonistic pleiotropy as a widespread mechanism for the maintenance of polymorphic disease alleles, BMC Medical Genetics (2011) – europepmc.org
- Luzzatto L.: Sickle cell anemia and malaria, Mediterranean Journal of Hematology and Infectious Diseases (2012) – europepmc.org
- National Human Genome Research Institute: Human Genomic Variation (as of 2023) – genome.gov
The terms relating to gene variants and mutations are based on [1]; the statement about predisposition comes from another page on the same site (“What does it mean to have a genetic predisposition to a disease?”, NLM, 2021). Antagonistic pleiotropy and the model associated with it come from [2]. Information about sickle cell trait and its connection to malaria is based on [3]. The information about the number and effects of variants comes from [4]. Information about NutriCare | The INFINITY DNA test details come from the mybody®x product pages; information current as of 04.10.2026.
mybody®x editorial and expert team
Human genetics Gene variants
This article was written by the mybody®x editorial and expert team and is based on the sources listed above. Find out who writes and reviews our content on the author page.
Published on 04.10.2026 · Last updated on 04.10.2026
The content is for general information and is no substitute for medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
Our products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent diseases.
DNA analysis is intended for nutritional and lifestyle advice. It is not a diagnostic procedure, does not predict disease, and is no substitute for a medical examination or advice. Genetic variants describe probabilities in population groups, not certainties for individuals.
The images in this article were created using AI; the people depicted are not real.
