News

The keto diet: what it involves and who it isn’t suitable for

ca. 23 Minuten

Keto-Ernährung: was dahintersteckt und für wen sie nicht taugt

The essentials

A ketogenic diet reduces carbohydrates to about five percent of energy intake, or around 25 grams a day. The consumer advice center considers it highly concerning and sees no advantage over a moderately low-carbohydrate diet. The DGE recommends that more than 50 percent of the energy in a balanced diet come from carbohydrates.

This article explains what happens in the body on keto and presents the views of two independent institutions. Both belong together: the mechanism is undisputed, but its evaluation is not. This article also makes clear where the sources reviewed are silent.

First, you’ll learn what a ketogenic diet means in practical terms. Then we’ll cover the institutions’ assessments, the groups for whom it isn’t suitable, the figures on weight loss, an overview of allowed and excluded foods, and a detailed section on how to tell if it isn’t right for you.

What to expect in this article

1. What a ketogenic diet actually is
2. What the institutions say
3. Who shouldn’t try keto
4. How many carbohydrates are normal
5. What really happens when you lose weight
6. What’s allowed, what’s limited, and what’s cut out
7. What a typical keto day looks like
8. How to tell it isn’t right for you
9. Three persistent myths
10. How to find out what suits your body
11. Limitations: what a DNA test can’t do
12. What you can change starting tomorrow
Frequently asked questions
Sources

What a ketogenic diet actually is

A ketogenic diet is first and foremost a calculation. Carbohydrates are reduced so much that the body no longer meets most of its energy needs from them. The consumer advice center puts this at about five percent of energy intake, or around 25 grams of carbohydrates a day for a 2,000-kilocalorie diet (2022).

For comparison: A medium-sized banana has about this many carbohydrates. So does a slice of bread. This isn’t about eating less sugar, but about changing the makeup of your plate.

Key point

The difference between a ketogenic and a moderately low-carbohydrate diet isn’t a matter of degree but a leap: 25 versus up to 140 grams of carbohydrates a day.

What the name means

The term comes from ketone bodies. When the body has very few carbohydrates available for a long time, it produces substitute fuels from fat that the brain can use. This state gives the diet its name.

The mechanism itself is undisputed. What is debated is whether it makes sense to induce it permanently. This is exactly where advertising claims and institutional assessments diverge.

For sports, the DGE describes a ketogenic composition with 75 to 85 percent of energy from fat, 15 to 25 percent from protein, and under 50 grams of carbohydrates a day (DGE, position paper on fats in sports nutrition, 2019). This makes the scale tangible: fat provides four-fifths of the energy.

Where the line for Low Carb lies

The two terms are often mentioned together, but they mean different things. The consumer advice center describes a moderately low-carbohydrate diet as one in which up to 35 percent of energy, or no more than 140 grams a day, comes from carbohydrates (2022).

The entire difference in this article lies between 25 and 140 grams. Anyone who says Low Carb but means keto is confusing an adjustment with a complete overhaul.

What the institutions say

Few dietary approaches show such a wide gap between public enthusiasm and institutional assessment. The strongest statement comes from the consumer advice centers.

Documented source

“Medical professionals and researchers consider ketogenic diets, in which you virtually eliminate carbohydrates, to be very concerning.”

Consumer advice center
High-fat and high-protein diets, as of 10.02.2022

The sentence reflects experts’ assessment and appears on a page that the consumer advice center attributes to itself. It addresses its readers formally, which is why the quotation uses “you” in its formal sense rather than “you” informally.

The same source gives the reason. A ketogenic diet offers no advantage over a moderately low-carbohydrate diet; instead, side effects such as headaches, weakness, and dizziness are possible (consumer advice center, 2022). So the effort is greater, but the payoff is not.

What the DGE says and what it does not

Precision is needed here because advice articles often claim more than the evidence supports. The German Nutrition Society has not published a standalone position on ketogenic diets as a weight-loss method that could be found in this research.

What the DGE does have is a guideline: a balanced mixed diet should contain limited amounts of fat and more than 50 percent of energy intake in the form of carbohydrates (DGE, carbohydrate reference values). A ketogenic diet contains around five percent. The difference speaks for itself, but this is an inference, not a ban.

So anyone who reads somewhere that the DGE advises against keto should check what that claim is based on. The substantiated rejection comes from the consumer advice center, not the DGE.

Who should not try keto

This chapter is deliberately placed near the beginning. A text that leaves the exclusion criteria until the end will miss exactly the reader they are meant for.

Get medical advice first or leave it alone

Diabetes

The consumer advice center explicitly advises against trying reduced-carbohydrate diets without first consulting a family doctor or diabetes clinic (2022)

Elevated uric acid levels or a history of gout

The Verbraucherzentrale cites an increased risk of gout attacks and kidney stones (2022).

Kidney disease

For the same reason, and because the protein proportion inevitably increases on keto

Pregnancy and breastfeeding

A diet that excludes entire food groups is the wrong approach here.

History of an eating disorder

Strict lists of forbidden foods and constant counting are not harmless methods with this history.

Regular use of medication

Such a far-reaching change belongs in a discussion with a doctor, not in a self-experiment.

The first two points are quoted verbatim from the Verbraucherzentrale. The other four are assessments and have no source citation because the sources reviewed do not support them. This is explicitly indicated rather than dressed up with a made-up source.

Why particular caution is needed with diabetes

A diet that cuts carbohydrates by four-fifths changes precisely the factor on which diabetes treatment is based. Anyone taking medication whose dosage is adjusted to a particular carbohydrate intake also changes the effect of that medication by changing their diet.

That is why the Verbraucherzentrale’s warning is so explicit. The question is not whether a low-carb diet is generally an option for diabetes, but that the change must take place alongside the medical care guiding the treatment.

What is excluded from a vegetarian diet

For vegetarians and vegans, there is an additional problem, shown in the overview in Chapter 6. Legumes are listed under “excluded,” and they are also the most important plant-based source of protein.

Anyone who wants to increase their protein intake without meat or legumes has only eggs, dairy products, and nuts left to choose from. That is a very narrow basis for a long-term diet.

How many carbohydrates are normal

Three figures put the whole discussion into perspective. They come from two different sources and describe the same value: the proportion of carbohydrates in energy intake.

Proportion of carbohydrates in energy intake

over 50%

DGE guideline for a balanced mixed diet

up to 35%

moderately low-carb, no more than 140 g per day

around 5%

ketogenic, about 25 g per day at 2,000 kcal

Sources: German Nutrition Society, carbohydrate reference values; Verbraucherzentrale, 2022

What happens when carbohydrates are eliminated

The DGE describes the consequence matter-of-factly: Reducing the proportion of carbohydrates in the diet inevitably increases the proportion of fat and/or protein (DGE, Position Paper 2011).

This is the key point that gets overlooked in marketing copy. Cutting out carbohydrates means adding something else. With a ketogenic diet, that’s mainly fat—and in quantities that are unusual in everyday life.

What really happens when you lose weight

The rapid initial success is real and is regularly misinterpreted. The consumer advice center notes that with low-carbohydrate diets, people often lose weight quickly at first, but initially lose mainly two to three kilograms of water (2022).

Losing two to three kilograms in the first week feels like proof. It isn’t. That’s why a ketogenic diet feels more effective in the first few days than any other dietary change.

According to the same source, weight loss from low-carb diets over twelve months is usually between five and ten percent of starting weight (2022). For weight-loss programs in general, IQWiG cites three to eight kilograms over six to twelve months, averaging five to six (2022).

Why the type of diet makes little difference

This is the most reliable statement in this entire article, and it comes from IQWiG. An analysis of studies comparing different weight-loss programs found that it makes little difference whether you eat a diet that is lower in fat or carbohydrates (IQWiG, 2022).

If the direction of the change barely matters, something else does: whether you can stick with it. The same source notes that many diets fail in the long term or even cause a yo-yo effect, in which weight is higher some time after the diet than before it (IQWiG, 2022).

What the yo-yo effect has to do with the method

IQWiG notes that many diets fail in the long term or even cause a yo-yo effect, in which weight is higher some time after the diet than before it (2022). This statement isn’t about keto in particular, but it describes the pattern that can result from a dietary change that can’t be maintained over time.

The tighter the restrictions, the bigger the adjustment when you return to your usual diet. At 25 grams of carbohydrates a day, there’s no half portion of bread—only before and after. This isn’t a matter of willpower, but a feature of the concept.

What’s allowed, what’s limited, what’s eliminated

The following overview assigns common food groups to the three levels based on the limit of around 25 grams of carbohydrates per day. This is a classification by carbohydrate content, not a recommendation.

Food group Level Note
Meat, fish, eggs allowed Practically carbohydrate-free and therefore the foundation of any ketogenic meal plan
Oils, butter, cream allowed The proportion of fat inevitably increases when carbohydrates are cut out (DGE, 2011)
Leafy greens, cabbage, zucchini allowed The only vegetable group that fits into the daily budget in significant amounts
Cheese and quark allowed Aged cheese contains very few carbohydrates; cream cheese products contain somewhat more
Nuts and seeds reduced Varies considerably by type. With a 25 g daily budget, even a handful counts
Milk and yogurt reduced Milk sugar is a carbohydrate. A large glass uses up a noticeable share of the budget
Berries reduced The only fruit group usually still included in small amounts
Bread, pasta, rice, potatoes cut out Just one slice of bread already uses up a significant part of the daily budget
Legumes cut out For a vegetarian diet, this removes the most important source of protein
Fruit other than berries cut out A medium-sized banana contains roughly as many carbohydrates as the entire daily budget
Sugar and sweets cut out The only item on the list that the DGE also recommends limiting in a balanced diet

What stands out in this overview is that the “cut out” column consists almost entirely of plant-based foods. Grains, legumes, and fruit are exactly the food groups that should make up the largest share of a balanced diet.

This explains the German Consumer Advice Center’s assessment better than any list of side effects. A way of eating that cuts out three of the five basic food groups is no minor adjustment.

What a keto day looks like in practice

Two examples, measured against a budget of around 25 grams of carbohydrates. They show just how tight this limit is in everyday life.

A day that adds up

Scrambled eggs with butter and spinach in the morning. Pan-fried salmon with zucchini and olive oil for lunch. Salad with aged cheese, nuts, and an oil-and-vinegar dressing in the evening. In between: water, coffee without milk, and unsweetened tea.

This day includes no bread, no side dish, and no fruit apart from perhaps a small serving of berries. It can be put together, and for many people it is appealing for the first week.

A day that goes off track

The same day, with a glass of milk in your coffee, an apple in the afternoon, and a slice of bread at dinner. Each of these three little things seems harmless on its own, but together they push you well over budget.

This is exactly where the practical difference from a moderately low-carb diet lies. At 140 grams a day, an apple and a slice of bread are part of the plan. At 25 grams, they derail it.

What most often gets in the way in everyday life

Three situations regularly throw the plan off course: the cafeteria that serves a side with every meal; the restaurant where the low-carb option is a special order; and the household where meals are cooked for several people, only one of whom eats keto.

In all three cases, the eating style isn't the problem; the environment is. If you know that beforehand, you can plan differently or choose a more flexible approach. If you discover it along the way, you think you're undisciplined.

How to tell if it doesn't fit you

This section is why this article exists. It's more detailed than the rest because ketogenic diets are more often abandoned than maintained, and the decision to stop rarely comes down to willpower.

The consumer advice center lists headaches, weakness, and dizziness as possible side effects (2022). If they occur and persist for days, that's not a sign of adjustment, but something to take seriously.

Fictional scenario for illustration

Example: Sandra, 41

Sandra switches to a ketogenic diet on a Monday. In the first week, the scale shows two and a half kilograms less, and she's convinced she's finally found the right thing. By week three, she has headaches, which she blames on too little sleep. In week five, she eats bread for the first time in a month because there's a birthday coming up. After that, getting back on track is hard because the plan doesn't allow for half measures. After eight weeks, she weighs as much as before and thinks she's undisciplined. In reality, she tried an eating style whose suitability for everyday life the consumer advice center explicitly calls into question.

Four signs suggest this eating style doesn't fit your life. First: You regularly eat out or in a cafeteria. Second: You cook for a family that eats normally. Third: You do endurance sports and notice a drop in performance. Fourth: After two weeks, you think about food more than before, not less.

None of these points is a medical criterion. All four determine whether a dietary change lasts six months. And according to the IQWiG review, that's exactly what matters, because the direction of the change hardly affects the outcome anyway.

The difference between dietary change and deprivation

A dietary change that works in everyday life changes what you eat. One that feels like deprivation changes your relationship with food. The difference rarely shows up in the first week and almost always does by the sixth.

A useful test is what happens when you're invited to someone's home. If you can follow your eating style without having to explain it, it works for you. If it requires an announcement to the hosts, an excuse to avoid the food, or making up for it the next day, it becomes an exception in everyday life.

This isn’t an argument against commitment. It’s an argument for choosing a framework that makes commitment possible in the first place. With 140 grams of carbohydrates, dinner with friends is part of the plan; with 25 grams, it’s a break from it.

When to stop and seek medical advice

The Verbraucherzentrale lists headaches, weakness and dizziness as possible side effects. If they last for several days or get worse, they should be checked out, not ignored.

The same applies to new joint pain, because the same source notes an increased risk of gout attacks. It also applies to discomfort when urinating or pain in your side, as these can indicate kidney stones, which the source also says carry an increased risk.

None of these symptoms is proof. All are a reason to stop and ask someone who can assess your health. If you notice warning signs, don’t change your diet; make an appointment.

Three persistent claims

Common versus evidence-based

Common

“Keto works better than other diets.”

Evidence-based

A review of studies found that it makes little difference whether you eat a diet that is higher in fat or lower in carbohydrates (IQWiG, 2022). The Verbraucherzentrale sees no advantage over a moderately low-carb diet (2022).

Common

“The first few kilos prove that it works.”

Evidence-based

At first, low-carb diets mainly cause a loss of two to three kilograms of water (Verbraucherzentrale, 2022).

Common

“Keto is just low carb, but more strict.”

Evidence-based

Moderately low-carb means up to 35 percent of energy or no more than 140 grams a day, while ketogenic means about 5 percent or around 25 grams (Verbraucherzentrale, 2022). That’s a fivefold difference.

How to find out what suits your body

When the direction of a dietary change makes little difference, whether it suits you personally becomes more important than the method itself. A DNA test by mybody®x (MYBODY Lab GmbH) offers some guidance, with a clear limitation.

DNA metabolism analysis by mybody®x (MYBODY Lab GmbH)

Saliva DNA test

DNA metabolism analysis | incl. 28-day plan & recipe book

According to the product page, it provides insights into genetic fundamentals and helps you find foods that fit your everyday life. Important for this topic: The product page makes no claims about ketogenic diets. So the test doesn’t tell you whether keto is right for you, and it doesn’t provide a diagnosis.

Price €197.00 As of 28.08.2026, subject to change
Sample type Saliva sample
Processing time Kit shipping: 1–3 business days
Lab analysis: 15–25 business days after sample receipt
Included 28-day plan and recipe book
Product page information, accessed 08/28/2026
About the DNA Metabolism Analysis

The test includes the MY FOODBOOK with 60 recipe ideas tailored to the individual results. It shows how results can be turned into specific meals instead of another list of prohibitions.

Chapter at a glance

According to the IQWiG assessment, it makes little difference to weight-loss success whether someone eats a diet that is lower in fat or lower in carbohydrates (2022). This shifts the key question from the method to how sustainable it is. A DNA test can provide clues about a person's predisposition, but it does not indicate whether a ketogenic diet is suitable.

Limitations: what a DNA test cannot do

A DNA test describes a predisposition, not a certainty. It does not provide a diagnosis or predict weight-loss success. Specifically regarding ketogenic diets: the product page does not cover this topic, and this article makes no claims about what it does not say.

This article also has a limitation in terms of content. The reviewed sources address ketogenic diets as a weight-loss method and their side effects. They do not address their use in medical contexts, where they are used under medical supervision. That is a different field and does not belong in a nutrition article.

A third limitation concerns the overview in Chapter 6. It categorizes food groups by their carbohydrate content. The number of grams in a specific product is listed on its packaging, not in this table.

What this article deliberately does not do

It cites no studies showing a particular benefit of a ketogenic diet. Not because none exist, but because no assessment of them appears in the sources this editorial team is permitted to use. A study without an assessment by a specialist institution is the weakest basis there is for an informational article.

It also gives no target levels for ketone bodies and no methods for measuring them. The sources reviewed do not address this, and this article does not include numbers without a source.

What follows is not a recommendation against a ketogenic diet. It is the observation that the reliable findings are more cautious than the public enthusiasm, and that everyone should be aware of this gap before making a change.

What you can change starting tomorrow

If you take away just one thing from this article, let it be this: before you cut carbohydrates to 25 grams, try 140. That is the limit the Verbraucherzentrale describes as moderately low-carb, and it sees no disadvantage compared with keto.

The reason is practical. At 140 grams, bread, fruit, and a side dish are still options. That makes it easier for a dietary change to last through a birthday, a business trip, and an evening with family, and according to the IQWiG review, that matters more than which approach you choose.

If you still decide to follow this restrictive approach, take two precautions. First, honestly go through the exclusion criteria in Chapter 3, and if you have diabetes, gout, or kidney disease, talk to your doctor beforehand. Second, set a date in advance to check whether it is still working for you. Without that date, a trial becomes a situation that no one ever reassesses.

It started with the question of what lies behind the keto diet. The honest answer is: a plausible mechanism and an assessment that is much more cautious than its reputation. Both belong in the same answer.

Frequently asked questions

How many carbohydrates are allowed on a ketogenic diet?

About five percent of your energy intake, or around 25 grams a day on a 2,000-kilocalorie diet (Verbraucherzentrale, 2022). For comparison: a moderately low-carb diet allows up to 35 percent, or no more than 140 grams daily, while the German Nutrition Society recommends getting more than 50 percent of your energy from carbohydrates as part of a balanced diet. This puts the factor between ketogenic and moderately low-carb diets at about five.

Do you lose weight faster with keto than with other diets?

During the first few days, the scales often show a noticeably lower weight, but at first this is mainly two to three kilograms of water (Verbraucherzentrale, 2022). Over twelve months, weight loss on low-carb diets is usually between five and ten percent of the starting weight. An IQWiG review of studies also found that it makes little difference whether you eat a diet that is lower in fat or carbohydrates (2022).

Who should avoid a ketogenic diet?

The Consumer Advice Center expressly advises people with diabetes not to try low-carbohydrate diets without first consulting their family doctor or diabetes clinic (2022). The same source notes an increased risk of gout attacks and kidney stones. For people with kidney disease, during pregnancy and breastfeeding, with a history of an eating disorder, or taking medication regularly, such a change should be discussed with a doctor.

What side effects are possible?

The Consumer Advice Center lists headaches, weakness, and dizziness as possible side effects of ketogenic diets and notes that the risk of gout attacks and kidney stones increases (2022). The IQWiG notes generally that such diets can be unbalanced and may cause side effects (2022). If symptoms persist for days, that’s not a sign of getting used to it.

Can a DNA test tell me whether keto is right for me?

No. The DNA Metabolism Analysis product page makes no claims about ketogenic diets. It describes insights into genetic foundations and guidance on which foods may suit your everyday life. A DNA test does not provide a diagnosis or predict weight loss success. If you want to know whether a particular diet is suitable for you, check the exclusion criteria in Chapter 3 and consult a doctor if in doubt.

Next step

A starting point, not a method

If the direction of the dietary change makes little difference, looking at your own predisposition may be more worthwhile than trying the next diet. The DNA Metabolism Analysis offers some insights. It does not replace medical advice or evaluate any particular diet.

View DNA Metabolism Analysis Protein-rich foods

Read more

You might also be interested in

Protein-rich foods at a glance: what really matters

Since the proportion of protein inevitably increases on a ketogenic diet, it’s worth taking a look at the figures behind it.

Iron-rich foods for iron deficiency: what really matters

The effects of cutting out entire food groups show up first in the nutrients from grains and legumes.

Sources

  1. Consumer Advice Center: High-fat and high-protein diets (as of 10.02.2022) – verbraucherzentrale.de
  2. Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG): Weight loss programs and medications (as of 2022) – gesundheitsinformation.de
  3. German Nutrition Society (DGE): Reference values for carbohydrate intake – dge.de
  4. German Nutrition Society (DGE): Guidelines for energy intake from carbohydrates and fat, position paper (2011) – dge.de

The direct quotation assessing ketogenic diets, the figures for carbohydrate amounts in ketogenic and moderately low-carbohydrate diets, the side effects, the guidance for people with diabetes, and the figures on water and weight loss come from source [1]. The study analysis comparing low-fat and low-carbohydrate diets, the information on the yo-yo effect, and the weight figures for weight-loss programs come from [2]. The guideline of more than 50 percent of energy intake from carbohydrates comes from [3], and the statement that the proportion of fat and protein necessarily increases comes from [4]. Information on the composition of a ketogenic diet in sports comes from the position paper “Fats in Sports Nutrition” by the German Nutrition Society, published in Ernährungs Umschau international 9/2019; under the rule for institutional sources attributed in the body text, it does not appear in the numbered list. Information on price, sample type, scope, and included items comes from the mybody®x product page, accessed on 28.08.2026; processing times follow the central guideline for DNA tests. All sources were accessed and checked on 28.08.2026.

mybody®x (MYBODY Lab GmbH) Certificate / Quality Seal

mybody®x Editorial & Expert Team

Nutritional science Nutrigenetics Laboratory diagnostics Blood test interpretation

This article was created by the mybody®x editorial and expert team. The team brings together laboratory diagnostics, nutritional science, and the interpretation of blood tests. The contributors are listed on the authors page.

Published on 06.10.2025 · Last updated on 28.08.2026

The content is for general information and does not replace medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Reference ranges depend on the laboratory, method, and age; the information on your lab report is always authoritative.

mybody®x (MYBODY Lab GmbH) Certificate / Quality Seal

Read more

Latest posts

View all