DNA Test

Intermittent fasting doesn’t work the same way for everyone

ca. 17 Minuten

Intervallfasten wirkt nicht bei jedem gleich

The key points at a glance

No one disputes that people respond differently to the same type of diet. The more interesting question is whether this can be predicted.

The largest study on this question found no significant interaction between a genotype pattern and diet type among 609 participants. We’re reporting this result even though it runs counter to expectations about genetic testing.

You’ll read the cited source verbatim, three documented facts, three fact-checked statements, a precise account of what the study examines and what it doesn’t, and what genetic testing actually analyzes.

What to expect in this article

1. The claim and what it asserts
2. The documented source
3. What this study examined
4. Three documented facts
5. What the result means and what it doesn’t
6. Three statements fact-checked
7. What has specifically been established about intermittent fasting
8. The key point in one sentence
9. Why a null finding is valuable
10. What genetic testing tells us and what it doesn’t
11. Why the evidence class matters here
12. Who can benefit from genetic testing
13. The DNA metabolism analysis in detail
14. Limitations: what remains unknown
15. What matters about this topic
Frequently asked questions
Sources

The claim and what it asserts

The headline of this article contains a claim that breaks down into two very different statements.

The first is that people respond differently. This is undisputed and visible in every study with many participants, because their results vary.

The second is that you can predict who will respond in what way. This is the truly interesting claim, and the one that needs to be examined.

This article deals exclusively with the second question. We address energy balance and why someone might not lose weight while intermittent fasting in a separate, in-depth article, which we link to at the end.

And we’ll say up front where our review leads: The result is not what you would expect from a genetic testing provider. We’re including it anyway, because anything else would go against our own standards.

The documented source

The sentence comes from a twelve-month randomized study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association.

Documented source

“There was no significant diet-genotype pattern interaction (p = 0.20) or diet-insulin secretion (INS-30) interaction (p = 0.47) with 12-month weight loss.”

Gardner CD et al., DIETFITS Randomized Clinical Trial
JAMA 2018;319(7):667–679 · Translated by the mybody®x editorial team

In our own translation: There was no significant interaction between diet and genotype pattern, and none between diet and insulin secretion, in terms of weight loss after twelve months.

The two numbers in parentheses are what are known as p-values. Put simply, a p-value of 0.20 means that a difference of this size would occur by chance alone in about one in five studies with no real association. The usual threshold for considering a result statistically significant is 0.05.

So the value is not just slightly off, but substantially so. That matters when interpreting it.

What this study tested

To read the result correctly, you need to know exactly what was tested. The study design is unusually clear.

609 adults were randomly assigned to one of two diets, low-fat or low-carbohydrate, and followed for twelve months. 481 of them completed the study.

Before the study began, everyone’s genotype pattern was determined. The question was: Do people with a particular pattern lose more weight on one diet than on the other?

That is exactly the question behind the idea that a genetic test could tell someone which diet suits them. It was asked in advance, not searched for afterward in the data.

The answer was: no significant interaction. Neither the genotype pattern nor the measured insulin level predicted which of the two diets worked better for whom.

Three documented figures

Three figures from the sources reviewed. They provide context and do not constitute a diagnosis.

Documented figures

609

Adults were followed for twelve months; 481 completed the study (Gardner et al., JAMA 2018)

p = 0.20

was the p-value for the interaction between diet and genotype pattern; a value below 0.05 is generally considered statistically significant (Gardner et al., JAMA 2018)

no recommendation

DGE’s guidance on how often healthy adults should eat each day to lose or maintain weight (2012)

The third figure comes from a different context, but is still relevant here. Two independent sources reach the same pattern on two related questions: the evidence does not support a general rule.

What the result means and what it does not

Results like this are overstated in both directions, and both overstatements are wrong.

It does not mean that genes played no role in metabolism. The study tested a specific genotype pattern for a specific prediction, not the overall significance of genes.

It also does not mean that genetic analyses tell us nothing. An analysis can provide information about how individual substances are processed, and that is a different kind of claim from predicting the success of a particular diet.

What it means is narrowly defined and still significant: For the question of which of the two diets studied worked better for whom, the genotype pattern tested was not a useful predictor.

Anyone drawing a dietary recommendation from genetic analysis must be measured against this study. That applies to every provider, including us.

Three facts in context

These three statements come up whenever genes and nutrition are mentioned together.

Checked against the evidence

Commonly claimed

“A genetic test tells me which type of diet is right for me.”

Supported by evidence

Over twelve months, the DIETFITS study found no significant interaction between diet type and genotype pattern in relation to weight loss among 609 participants (Gardner et al., JAMA 2018).

Commonly claimed

“So genes tell us nothing at all about metabolism.”

Supported by evidence

That is not what the study says. It tested a specific pattern for a specific prediction. It makes no claims about other analyses, such as those concerning the metabolic pathways of individual substances.

Commonly claimed

“There are specific genetic markers for intermittent fasting.”

Supported by evidence

We found no source on genetic predictions specifically for intermittent fasting in the category we require for such claims. So we cite none.

What is specifically supported by evidence on intermittent fasting

The DIETFITS study compared a low-fat diet with a low-carbohydrate diet, not different eating windows. So, as far as intermittent fasting itself is concerned, it is only an analogy.

We therefore specifically searched for sources on genetic predictions for intermittent fasting and found none that met our requirements for source category and recency.

What we found is the position of the German Nutrition Society on meal frequency. It states that, based on the available evidence, no firm recommendations can be made about how often healthy people should eat each day to lose or maintain body weight (2012).

Together, these two findings paint a picture. There is no reliable rule for either the type of diet or how often to eat, and certainly none for combining genetic analysis with a time window.

We write that down and do not fill the gap with a guess. It is the uncomfortable option and the only one that fits our own rules.

The key point in one sentence

At this point, we can bring the topic together.


That people respond differently is undisputed. The largest study on the subject did not confirm that this could be predicted from a genotype pattern.

The entire difference between an observation and a prediction lies between these two statements.

An observation only requires that something happens. A prediction requires being able to say in advance who it will happen to. That second step is the difficult one.

Why a null result is valuable

A result that finds no association may seem disappointing at first. For practical purposes, it is often more valuable than a positive result.

The reason lies in the study design. This study asked the question in advance, randomly assigned participants, and ran for twelve months. This is the kind of design that would find an association if one existed.

When a study with this kind of design finds nothing, that is robust information. It is worth far more than a small analysis that searches the data after the fact and finds something.

For someone considering whether to use a genetic analysis to make a dietary decision, this information is useful. It tells them what not to expect and protects them from disappointment.

Why such results appear less often

There’s a reason null results are less commonly seen in everyday life than positive findings, and it has to do with how the system works.

A study that finds an association is easier to turn into a headline than one that doesn’t. It gets cited more often, shared more often, and incorporated into product copy more often.

Anyone who wants to assess the state of the evidence should know this. What you often come across online is not the same as what the body of research as a whole shows.

For this article, that means we cite the study that asked this question most rigorously, not the one whose results would best fit. That’s the whole difference.

What a genetic analysis says and what it doesn’t

The table distinguishes which claims are addressed by the study and which are not. It provides context and does not make a diagnosis.

Type of claim Example Addressed by DIETFITS? Assessment
Prediction of a diet “A low-carbohydrate diet is a better fit for you” Yes, directly No significant interaction found, p = 0.20 (Gardner et al., JAMA 2018)
Prediction of a time window “Intermittent fasting works especially well for you” Not directly; the study did not examine time windows We found no source of sufficient quality on this, so we are not citing one
Information about a metabolic pathway Categories for caffeine, alcohol, or lactose metabolism No, the study did not examine that A separate question; the findings are described in the relevant analysis report
Statement about the current state “Your ferritin level is X” No, a genetic analysis is not designed for that A blood test answers that, not a genetic test

The first row is the one that matters. Anyone who buys a genetic analysis expecting it to predict the right diet for them should have read this row.

The last row describes the most common confusion of all. A genetic variation never changes, but a blood value changes constantly. So they answer fundamentally different questions.

There is also a difference in the type of claim between the second and third rows. Information about a metabolic pathway describes how the body handles a substance. A prediction says what will work better in the future. The latter is much harder to substantiate than the former.

Why the type of source matters here

There are many publications in this field, but very few we can rely on. So, a word about our approach.

We prefer to rely on German-language institutions such as IQWiG, the German Nutrition Society, and the Federal Joint Committee, because they have already assessed the evidence.

On this topic, these institutions offer no guidance on genetic prediction. We therefore turn to primary research and make this explicit, as we did in an earlier article on vitamin D and magnesium.

The criteria for selection are therefore: randomized design, a question formulated in advance, a sufficient number of participants, a long duration, and a respected journal. The DIETFITS study meets all five criteria.

We do not cite studies that fail to meet these criteria for questions like this, even if their findings would better support a product.

One criterion deserves particular attention: a question formulated in advance. If you search a large dataset for long enough, you will find associations purely by chance. Only a question established before the analysis rules this out.

That is precisely the significance of the study cited here. It asked the genotype question in advance and randomly assigned participants, rather than looking for patterns afterward.

Who can benefit from genetic analysis

This comparison addresses whether genetic analysis offers any benefit in your situation.

It may be right for you if …

You are interested in the specific analysis categories, such as caffeine or lactose metabolism.

You want a one-time analysis that, unlike blood values, does not need to be repeated.

You know that the available evidence does not support predicting the right diet for you, and do not expect it to.

You can allow 15 to 25 working days for processing.

Probably not, if …

You expect it to predict the right diet for you. The available evidence does not support this.

You want to know whether intermittent fasting works for you. We have found no reliable source on this.

You want to see your current values. That calls for a blood test, not a genetic test.

You have symptoms. In that case, you need a medical evaluation.

DNA metabolism analysis in detail

A genetic analysis does not provide a diagnosis and is no substitute for medical evaluation. It describes genetic variations that do not change over the course of your life.

The following information comes from the mybody®x product page (MYBODY Lab GmbH), accessed on 19 August 2026. Based on everything stated in this article, we present it as a description, not a promise.

DNA metabolism analysis

Genetic analysis from saliva

DNA metabolism analysis

According to the product page, evaluates more than 80 genetic variations across categories covering diet and nutrition, the need for vitamins B6, B9, B12, D, and E, as well as iron, sodium, and potassium, and metabolic function, including alcohol, caffeine, and lactose metabolism, as well as gluten tolerance. What the analysis does not do: It does not predict whether intermittent fasting will work for you, measure current blood values, or make a diagnosis.

Price from €197.00 As of 19.08.2026, subject to change
Sample type Saliva sample
Processing time 15–25 business days after sample receipt
Information from the product page, accessed 19.08.2026
Laboratory Analysis in Germany, certified according to ISO 9001, ISO 13485 and ISO 27001
Information from the product page, accessed 19.08.2026
About the DNA metabolic analysis

Chapter at a glance

The analysis evaluates genetic variations related to diet, nutrient requirements, and metabolic function. The DIETFITS study found no reliable link between genetic variations and predicting which diet works better for whom. The analysis does not measure current blood values, make a diagnosis, or replace medical evaluation.

Limitations: what remains unanswered

The first limitation is extrapolation. The DIETFITS study compared a low-fat diet with a low-carbohydrate diet, not eating windows. For intermittent fasting, it is an analogy, not direct evidence.

The second limitation is the scope of the result. It concerns predicting which diet works best, not the overall significance of genes.

The third limitation is our source material. We did not find a sufficiently high-quality source on genetic predictions specifically for intermittent fasting, so we do not make any.

The fourth limitation is the age of the study. It dates from 2018. If a newer study with a comparable design reaches a different conclusion, we will correct this article.

The fifth limitation is diagnosis. All assessments in this article provide context and do not constitute a diagnosis. A single lab result is always just one piece of an overall diagnosis (IQWiG, as of 02.04.2025).

What matters on this topic

If you take away just one thing from this article, let it be this: distinguish between the observation that people respond differently and the claim that this can be predicted.

For this prediction, there is a large, well-designed study with a clear result: there was no significant interaction between diet and genotype pattern in terms of weight loss after twelve months (Gardner et al., JAMA 2018).

We could have written this article differently. The fact that we didn't is the real takeaway: an article that takes numbers and sources seriously also presents findings that don't fit the narrative.

Frequently asked questions

Can a genetic analysis predict which dietary pattern is right for me?

For this question, the DIETFITS study found no significant interaction between diet type and genotype pattern in terms of weight loss among 609 adults over twelve months (Gardner et al., JAMA 2018;319(7):667–679). Anyone buying a genetic analysis with this expectation should know about this result.

Does that mean genes play no role in metabolism?

No. The study examined a specific genotype pattern for a specific prediction: which of two dietary patterns would work better for whom. It makes no claims about other analyses, such as those relating to the ways individual substances like caffeine or lactose are processed.

Are there studies specifically on genes and intermittent fasting?

We couldn't find a source that meets our standards for source quality and currency, so we aren't citing one. The DIETFITS study compared dietary patterns, not eating windows; applying it to intermittent fasting is an analogy.

What does the p-value of 0.20 mean?

Put simply: A difference of this size would occur by chance alone in about one in five cases in a study with no real association. The usual threshold for a statistically significant result is 0.05. So the value is well above that, not just barely over it.

Why am I still not losing weight with intermittent fasting?

This article deliberately does not address this question because it is a different one. We have a separate, detailed article on this, which examines energy balance with sources from the DGE, IQWiG, and WHO. It is linked under “Read more.”

Next step

What a genetic analysis actually evaluates

The DNA metabolic analysis evaluates more than 80 genetic variations, including categories related to alcohol, caffeine, and lactose metabolism. It does not predict whether intermittent fasting will work for you, measure current blood values, or provide a diagnosis.

About the DNA metabolic analysis

Read more

You might also be interested in

Why am I not losing weight with intermittent fasting?

The energy balance, worked out with sources.

Meal timing changes how your body responds

When timing demonstrably matters.

Sources

  1. Gardner CD, Trepanowski JF, Del Gobbo LC et al.: Effect of Low-Fat vs Low-Carbohydrate Diet on 12-Month Weight Loss in Overweight Adults and the Association With Genotype Pattern or Insulin Secretion: The DIETFITS Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA. 2018;319(7):667–679 - jamanetwork.com
  2. German Nutrition Society (DGE): Meal frequency and weight regulation in adults, technical information, July 2012 - dge.de
  3. Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG): Understanding laboratory results, as of 02.04.2025 - gesundheitsinformation.de

The verbatim English quotation, the p-values, the participant numbers of 609 and 481, the 12-month study duration, and the study design are from source [1]; the German rendering of the quotation is a translation by the mybody®x editorial team. The statement about meal frequency is from [2]. The sentence about being one component of an overall diagnosis is from [3]. The statement that we found no sufficiently high-quality source on genetic predictions specifically for intermittent fasting is based on a search conducted on 19.08.2026. The assessment categories, number of genetic variants, and details about price, sample type, processing time, and certification are from the mybody®x product page, accessed on 19.08.2026. All sources were accessed and checked on 19.08.2026.

mybody®x (MYBODY Lab GmbH) Certificate / Quality Seal

mybody®x Editorial & Expert Team

Laboratory diagnostics Blood test interpretation Nutritional science Nutrigenetics

This article was created by the mybody®x editorial and expert team. The team brings together laboratory diagnostics, nutritional science, and the interpretation of blood tests. You can find the people who contributed on the authors page.

Published on 19.08.2026 · Last updated on 19.08.2026

The content is for general information and does not replace medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Reference ranges depend on the laboratory, method, and age - the information on your test result is always authoritative.

mybody®x (MYBODY Lab GmbH) Certificate / Quality Seal

Read more

Latest posts

View all