Blood test

Hyperthyroidism or hypothyroidism? How to distinguish thyroid symptoms and what a self-check can show

October 28, 2026approx. 15 minutesby mybody®x Editorial & Expert Team

Über- oder Unterfunktion? Schilddrüsen-Symptome unterscheiden und was ein Selbstcheck zeigt

Key points

Hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism can cause partly opposite symptoms: With too much thyroid hormone, IQWiG (2024) lists sweating and weight loss despite increased appetite; with too little, feeling cold and slight to moderate weight gain. Fatigue occurs with both. Only the TSH (thyroid-stimulating hormone) level in the blood can show which condition is present (IQWiG, 2025).

IQWiG (2024) lists fatigue and changes to the hair among the symptoms of both disorders, so they do not indicate which one is present.

A US study found that individual symptoms were not very informative on their own, while several together are a reason to get a blood test (Canaris et al., 2000).

A self-check based on symptoms can be a reason to get a blood test, but it cannot confirm or rule out a thyroid disorder.

In this article

What symptoms does the thyroid cause with hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism?

The thyroid can produce too little or too much hormone, and each can cause its own symptoms. With hypothyroidism, the metabolism slows down (IQWiG, 2024); with hyperthyroidism, the possible signs tend to point in the opposite direction, such as a racing heart instead of a low pulse (IQWiG, 2024).

Hypothyroidism means that the thyroid produces too little thyroid hormone. When these hormones are lacking, the metabolism slows down, according to IQWiG (2024). Possible symptoms include sensitivity to cold and slight to moderate weight gain (IQWiG, 2024).

Hyperthyroidism is the opposite: the thyroid produces too much hormone. Among the possible symptoms, IQWiG (2024) lists palpitations and a racing heart, as well as weight loss despite increased appetite. Several of these signs mirror those of hypothyroidism, such as the low pulse in one case and the racing heart in the other (IQWiG, 2024). Only the TSH level in the blood can show which condition is actually present; this is covered in the chapter on blood values.

According to IQWiG (2024), hypothyroidism is the more common of the two conditions. In countries such as Germany, about 5 in 100 people have hypothyroidism, with women and older people particularly affected (IQWiG, 2024). Hyperthyroidism affects about 1 in 100 people (IQWiG, 2024). It is more common in women than in men, usually in middle adulthood (paraphrased from IQWiG, 2024).

An increase in TSH was also more common in a US survey: among visitors to a health fair in Colorado, 9.5% had elevated TSH and 2.2% had low TSH in the 1995 survey (Canaris et al., 2000). The figure is not representative and cannot be applied to Germany. An abnormal TSH result is also not yet a confirmed diagnosis.

Thyroid disorders in figures

5 in 100

people in countries such as Germany have hypothyroidism (IQWiG, 2024).

1 in 100

people have hyperthyroidism (IQWiG, 2024).

9,5 %

of participants in a US study had elevated TSH; survey conducted in 1995, not representative (Canaris et al., 2000).

Source: IQWiG, 2024; Canaris et al., 2000

Hypothyroidism can have various causes. IQWiG (2024) identifies Hashimoto's thyroiditis, a thyroid disease, as the most common cause. Read about how it presents in the article on Hashimoto's symptoms.

Which thyroid symptoms are consistent with both conditions?

IQWiG (2024) lists weakness and fatigue for both hypothyroidism and hyperthyroidism, along with changes to the hair. These symptoms do not distinguish between the two conditions; the differences are discussed in the next chapter.

If you have been feeling exhausted for weeks, you look for an explanation, and the thyroid is an obvious possibility. But fatigue alone does not indicate which condition it is: weakness and fatigue are listed as symptoms of both hypothyroidism and hyperthyroidism (IQWiG, 2024).

Hair changes are similar. For hypothyroidism, IQWiG (2024) lists dry hair and hair loss; for hyperthyroidism, thinning hair (IQWiG, 2024). This means thinning hair can be consistent with either condition. Learn more about hair loss and the thyroid in a separate article.

Key takeaway

Fatigue and thinning hair are consistent with both hypothyroidism and hyperthyroidism, so they do not indicate which one is present (IQWiG, 2024).

Mood can also change in both cases, but in different ways. IQWiG (2024) lists depression or other psychological symptoms for an underactive thyroid, and nervous restlessness and irritability for an overactive thyroid (IQWiG, 2024). Here, it is the type of change that differs, not the fact that a change occurs.

For your own assessment, this means that comparing the two disorders is not very helpful if your main symptom is fatigue. Symptoms that occur with only one of the disorders, such as feeling cold or sweating, may point more clearly in one direction. The next section compares them. None of these symptoms can provide certainty.

Overactive or underactive thyroid: How do the symptoms differ?

The two disorders show contrasting effects on temperature sensitivity and weight: IQWiG (2024) lists feeling cold and weight gain for an underactive thyroid, and sweating and weight loss despite increased appetite for an overactive thyroid. Still, no single symptom is conclusive.

According to IQWiG (2024), an overactive thyroid can cause symptoms such as:

  • Palpitations and rapid heartbeat, sometimes also heart rhythm disorders
  • High blood pressure
  • Weight loss despite increased appetite
  • Diarrhea
  • Trembling
  • Nervous restlessness and irritability
  • Insomnia
  • Weakness and fatigue

The table compares possible symptoms of both disorders as described by IQWiG (2024), with blood pressure and TSH added. Each row describes a possibility, not a symptom that everyone affected experiences. If you recognize yourself in one column, it may give you a starting point for a conversation with your doctor.

Possible symptoms compared

Category Underactive thyroid (IQWiG, 2024) Overactive thyroid (IQWiG, 2024)
Temperature Sensitivity to cold, feeling cold Sweating; heat quickly becomes uncomfortable
Weight and appetite slight to moderate weight gain Weight loss despite increased appetite
Heart low pulse Palpitations, rapid heartbeat
Skin dry, especially on the face, with a puffy thickening warm and moist
Mood and sleep Depression nervous restlessness and irritability; insomnia
Blood pressure more often, the lower reading is high (Streeten et al., 1988) high, especially the upper reading (IQWiG, 2024; Saito & Saruta, 1994)
TSH high (IQWiG, 2025) low (IQWiG, 2025)

No symptom proves a disorder. Blood test results bring clarity.

IQWiG (2024) also lists shortness of breath among the symptoms of an underactive thyroid. Women may also experience heavy periods or menstrual irregularities (IQWiG, 2024). Digestion shows the contrast once again: diarrhea is associated with an overactive thyroid (IQWiG, 2024), while IQWiG (2024) also lists constipation as a symptom of an underactive thyroid.

Sweating and constant hunger: Could this indicate an overactive thyroid?

Both are more suggestive of an overactive thyroid: IQWiG (2024) lists sweating and weight loss despite increased appetite as possible signs. Neither is proof; only the TSH level can help determine what’s going on (IQWiG, 2025).

The IQWiG (2024) description of sweating goes beyond sweat itself. It also covers how warmth is experienced and how the skin and hair feel.

Cited source

“People with an overactive thyroid often sweat and quickly find warmth uncomfortable; their skin often feels warm and moist, and their hair is thinning.”

Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG)
gesundheitsinformation.de, “Overactive thyroid (hyperthyroidism),” 2024

The opposite is sensitivity to cold, which IQWiG (2024) lists as a symptom of an underactive thyroid. Someone pulling their jacket tighter on the balcony in the evening while others sit in T-shirts is more likely to describe this side of the table.

When it comes to hunger, the combination matters. IQWiG (2024) does not refer to hunger alone, but to weight loss despite increased appetite: a big appetite, while weight still drops. Constant hunger with stable or rising weight does not match this description. What the term fast metabolism means is explained in a separate article.

Conversely, not sweating in old age does not rule out an overactive thyroid. In a clinical study, most classic symptoms of an overactive thyroid became less common with increasing age, with the exception of weight loss and shortness of breath (Boelaert et al., 2010). So even without typical symptoms, someone may still have an overactive thyroid.

Thyroid and blood pressure: Which number rises with an overactive or underactive thyroid?

With an overactive thyroid, the top, systolic number is more likely to be elevated (Saito & Saruta, 1994); with an underactive thyroid, the bottom, diastolic number can sometimes rise (Streeten et al., 1988). Both sources are older, from 1994 and 1988; this rule of thumb is a general guide, not a diagnostic sign.

Two dark cups on a wooden table, one with steaming tea, the other with iced water

A blood pressure reading consists of two numbers: the systolic is the top number, and the diastolic is the bottom number. This distinction matters for the thyroid because the two disorders affect different numbers in the 1988 and 1994 studies.

High blood pressure is listed among the possible symptoms of an overactive thyroid (IQWiG, 2024). A 1994 review clarifies the pattern: with an overactive thyroid, it is mainly the top number that is elevated, more often in younger people, while an elevated bottom number is unusual (Saito & Saruta, 1994).

A 1988 study describes how an underactive thyroid can sometimes be accompanied by an elevated bottom number (Streeten et al., 1988). At the hypertension clinic where the data came from, 3.6 % of referred patients had an underactive thyroid (Streeten et al., 1988). In 1.2 %, it was the cause of the elevated bottom number (Streeten et al., 1988). These figures are proportions among people who had already been referred for high blood pressure, not figures for the general population.

Another finding concerns older age: high blood pressure is more common among older people with an underactive thyroid than among their peers with normal thyroid function (Saito & Saruta, 1994).

Both studies (1988 and 1994) suggest a rule of thumb: an overactive thyroid tends to raise the top number, while an underactive thyroid tends to raise the bottom number. That is all it tells you. Blood pressure cannot show whether the thyroid is involved; blood tests are needed for that (IQWiG, 2025). A separate article explains which readings count as normal blood pressure.

Thyroid symptom test: What can a self-check show?

A symptom self-check can be a reason to get a blood test, but it cannot diagnose or rule out a thyroid disorder. This follows from a US study in which individual symptoms, taken on their own, revealed little (Canaris et al., 2000).

In the Colorado study, people with an underactive thyroid reported symptoms more often than people with normal thyroid function (Canaris et al., 2000). However, each individual symptom had low sensitivity (Canaris et al., 2000). Here, sensitivity means how reliably a symptom occurs in people who have the condition. When sensitivity is low, some people with the condition do not have the symptom, and its absence does not rule anything out.

The authors draw a practical conclusion: anyone reporting several thyroid symptoms should have their blood levels checked (Canaris et al., 2000).

With an overactive thyroid, there is a second caveat: its classic signs are much less common in older people, and their absence often leads to a delayed diagnosis (Boelaert et al., 2010).

For any list of symptoms, whether on paper or online, this means: it can be a good reason to have blood levels checked. It cannot diagnose or rule out thyroid disease. The idea that a questionnaire can reliably tell whether thyroid problems are present is not supported by these findings (Canaris et al., 2000; Boelaert et al., 2010).

The article on underactive thyroid explains in detail how it presents and what it looks like in older adults. Here, the focus is on comparing the two conditions and what a list of symptoms can tell you.

What you can write down before your appointment

  • which symptoms you’ve noticed and when they started
  • whether your weight has changed, and in which direction
  • your resting pulse, if you’ve measured it
  • your blood pressure, including the upper and lower readings, if you’ve measured it

The list doesn’t award points or produce a result. It helps make sure nothing is forgotten during the conversation; only blood test results can help put the symptoms into context.

Which blood test results show whether the thyroid is overactive or underactive?

The starting point is the TSH level: If it is within the reference range, that is enough to rule out thyroid dysfunction, according to the IQWiG (2025). High levels point to an underactive thyroid, while low levels may indicate an overactive thyroid (IQWiG, 2025).

Blood tests aren’t an add-on here; they’re central to the evaluation. “Because many symptoms of an underactive thyroid can also have other causes, blood tests are done to make a clear diagnosis,” writes the IQWiG (2024).

The reference range is the range the lab lists on the test result for comparison. It depends on the lab and the method, so always refer to the range shown on your own test result.

According to the IQWiG (2025), free thyroxine (fT4) is often measured alongside TSH, and free triiodothyronine (fT3) is sometimes measured as well. In an underactive thyroid, these free hormones are low; in an overactive thyroid, they are high (paraphrased from IQWiG, 2025). If only the TSH level is abnormal and the free hormones are normal, the IQWiG (2025) describes this as a latent form.

As the IQWiG (2025) puts it, a single lab result usually isn’t enough to conclude that someone has a disease. An abnormal result is therefore a reason to talk to a doctor, not a diagnosis. A separate article explains what a high TSH level can mean.

Anyone who wants to know their thyroid levels before speaking with a doctor can have them checked with the Women’s Wellness Check from mybody®x (MYBODY Lab GmbH): The capillary blood test, taken with a finger prick, measures TSH as well as fT3 and fT4, for €169.00 (as of October 28, 2026; subject to change). It provides a snapshot of the levels; thyroid antibodies are not included in its list of values. It can help prepare for a conversation at the doctor’s office, but does not replace a medical evaluation.

Thyroid: When should you get symptoms checked?

According to a US study, having several symptoms at once is a reason to get thyroid levels tested (Canaris et al., 2000). A racing heart or heart rhythm disorders, meaning a heartbeat that gets out of rhythm, also warrant a visit to the doctor.

The number of symptoms is one clue, not any one symptom on its own. Even when the symptoms fit in the same column of the table, such as feeling cold and weight gain, only blood test results can determine what they mean.

Two signs deserve special attention in older adults: weight loss and shortness of breath. In a clinic study, these were the signs that persisted in older adults with hyperthyroidism, while other classic signs became less common (Boelaert et al., 2010).

IQWiG (2024) lists a racing heart and heart rhythm disorders among the possible signs of hyperthyroidism. Regardless of the thyroid, they should be checked by a doctor. Anyone who notices them should not wait for the results of a questionnaire.

The next step in a medical practice is to discuss the symptoms and blood test results. The notes list from the self-check chapter makes this conversation easier; the doctor assesses the symptoms.

Chapter at a glance

According to a US study, having several symptoms at once is a reason to get a blood test (Canaris et al., 2000). A racing heart or heart rhythm disorders are possible signs of hyperthyroidism and warrant a visit to the doctor (IQWiG, 2024). In older adults, weight loss or shortness of breath may be the signs that persist while others become less common (Boelaert et al., 2010). Symptoms are assessed in a medical practice based on blood test results.

Limitations: How reliable is the information on thyroid symptoms?

IQWiG’s (2024) symptom lists name possible signs. The studies from 1988 to 2010 have clear limitations; the blood pressure figures are the oldest of them.

IQWiG (2024) lists symptoms of both disorders as possible signs, without giving the proportion of affected people for them. The table in this article therefore shows possibilities, not probabilities.

The Colorado study is a survey of visitors to a health fair in the US in 1995 (Canaris et al., 2000). It is not representative, and its proportions cannot be applied to Germany.

The study on hyperthyroidism in older adults comes from a single clinic (Boelaert et al., 2010). Only its summary was available for this article.

The information about blood pressure is based on a 1994 review and a 1988 study (Saito & Saruta, 1994; Streeten et al., 1988). The 1988 study included only people who had already been referred to a hypertension clinic. That’s why blood pressure is described here as tending to move in a particular direction and as something that may happen, not as a rule.

The blood test discussed in the chapter on blood tests also has limitations. Thyroid antibodies aren’t included in its list of results, and it doesn’t replace an ultrasound. It shows the current state, so it’s just a snapshot.

What does this mean for your thyroid symptoms?

Hyperthyroidism or hypothyroidism: symptoms alone can’t answer the question in the heading. Contrasts such as feeling cold versus sweating point in one direction, but fatigue and thinning hair do not. Several symptoms together are a good reason to get a blood test. The TSH level provides the context. So the symptom list belongs in a conversation at the doctor’s office, not in a score.

Frequently asked questions

How common is hyperthyroidism?

According to IQWiG (2024), hyperthyroidism affects about 1 in 100 people. It is more common in women than men, usually in middle adulthood (paraphrased from IQWiG, 2024). Hypothyroidism is more widespread, affecting about 5 in 100 people in countries such as Germany (IQWiG, 2024). In a US study of people attending a health fair, 2.2% had low TSH (Canaris et al., 2000). This figure is not representative and cannot be applied to Germany. A low result alone is not a diagnosis.

Can hypothyroidism cause shortness of breath?

Yes, that’s possible: IQWiG (2024) lists shortness of breath alongside a low pulse among the symptoms of hypothyroidism. It isn’t a clear-cut sign, since it also occurs with hyperthyroidism. In older people with hyperthyroidism, shortness of breath persisted in a clinical study, while other classic signs became less common with age (Boelaert et al., 2010). Shortness of breath should therefore be evaluated by a doctor, and an examination and blood tests can show what’s causing it.

Do older people have different symptoms of hyperthyroidism?

Older adults show fewer classic signs of hyperthyroidism, according to a clinical study of 3,049 people with hyperthyroidism (Boelaert et al., 2010). As age increased, most classic symptoms became less common, but weight loss and shortness of breath did not (Boelaert et al., 2010). The authors note that the absence of classic signs often delays diagnosis and suggest, in effect, testing thyroid levels more readily in people aged 60 and older (Boelaert et al., 2010). The study was conducted at a single clinic (Boelaert et al., 2010).

Is a thyroid questionnaire test informative?

A questionnaire can prompt a blood test, but nothing more. In a US study, people with hypothyroidism reported symptoms more often than people without it, but each symptom on its own revealed little (Canaris et al., 2000). The authors therefore recommend testing blood levels when several thyroid-related symptoms are present (Canaris et al., 2000). A questionnaire can neither diagnose nor rule out a disorder. Assessment requires the TSH level and, if needed, free hormone levels (IQWiG, 2025), as well as a discussion with a doctor.

Is TSH high or low in hyperthyroidism?

Low: According to IQWiG (2025), low TSH levels may indicate hyperthyroidism, while high levels indicate hypothyroidism. You can remember it this way: low TSH is consistent with hyperthyroidism, high TSH with hypothyroidism (IQWiG, 2025). According to IQWiG (2025), a result within the reference range is enough to rule out a thyroid disorder. However, a single result is not a diagnosis, because, according to IQWiG (2025), a disease usually cannot be inferred from a single lab result.

Next step

When the symptoms are more consistent with hypothyroidism

A separate article explains how hypothyroidism manifests in detail and how it is evaluated.

Hypothyroidism: symptoms and evaluation Understanding Hashimoto's symptoms Symptoms and diagnosis of Hashimoto's thyroiditis

Read more

Sources

  1. Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG): Overactive thyroid (hyperthyroidism) (as of 2024) – gesundheitsinformation.de
  2. Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG): Underactive thyroid (hypothyroidism) (as of 2024) – gesundheitsinformation.de
  3. Canaris G. J. et al.: The Colorado thyroid disease prevalence study, Archives of Internal Medicine (2000) – europepmc.org
  4. Boelaert K. et al.: Older subjects with hyperthyroidism present with a paucity of symptoms and signs, The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism (2010) – europepmc.org

The possible symptoms of both conditions and how common they are are based on [1] and [2], while the information on self-checks is based on [3] and [4]. The direction of the TSH value follows the IQWiG page Thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) (as of 2025), and the blood pressure information is based on the earlier papers by Saito & Saruta (1994) and Streeten et al. (1988). The list of values and the blood test price in the section on blood test results are based on information from mybody®x, as of October 28, 2026.

mybody®x (MYBODY Lab GmbH) Certificate / Quality Seal

mybody®x editorial and expert team

Thyroid Blood test results

This article was written by the mybody®x editorial and expert team and is based on health information from IQWiG and published studies. Find out who is behind the team on the authors page.

Published on October 28, 2026 · Last updated on October 28, 2026

The content is for general information and is no substitute for medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Reference ranges depend on the laboratory, method, and age – the information on your test results is always authoritative.

Our products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent diseases.

The images in this article were created using AI; the people shown are not real.

mybody®x (MYBODY Lab GmbH) Certificate / Quality Seal

Read more

Latest posts

View all